The Journal of Christopher Columbus and Guaman Poma

  The Journal of Christopher Columbus shed a great deal of light on colonialism and its eurocentric attitude. I knew of this previously to reading the journal, however, to read such discourse written in the first person was enlightening. I found it interesting how quickly Columbus seems to understand what the natives are saying. I wonder how much of this communication was reality and how much was based on assumption. Columbus seems to be a person who was quick to assume. Especially when it comes to the native people. He automatically assumes that they have no religion, and interestingly, he also assumes they think that he comes from heaven, or the sky. To me, it seems obvious that they have some form of worship however Columbus seems to ignore this, and put more importance on his own flattery. This same assumption of superiorty of Christianity is evident in the pages from the Guaman Poma reading. Fray Vicente say’s to Atagualpa that he should worship god and nothing else. To imagine the world so long ago is made easier with Columbus's description of the land. I envision his eyes widening at the sight of this land he has just set foot on and quickly claims his own by each footstep he takes.  The lush forest and the tropical fruits he describes makes me think of how the search for a pristine, ‘untouched’ paradise is still happening in our current culture. It makes me think of the photographs we see in tourism posters or magazines of seemingly unpopulated stretches of beach.  Is there still some evidence of colonialist behaviours or ideas in our society today? Perhaps not as extreme? In the Guaman Poma reading, and in the journal of Columbus, I got a strong sense of confidence from the Spaniards compared to the native people. Perhaps because they come from a more advanced civilization in regards to technology- they have more weapons. and they are not very quick to trust. The natives, although they are intimidated, seem somewhat trusting of their invaders. I almost find their trust to be more brave than the Spaniards who come armed.